Showing posts with label Accountability. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Accountability. Show all posts

Monday, August 15, 2016

Accountability and Economics

What Does the Book of Mormon Say About Inequality? Series

The Book of Mormon contains some surprising insights concerning economic inequality.  This series explores several topics addressed by the LDS scripture and its insights for today.

This article part of a chapter on the teachings of the Book of Mormon concerning inequality, organized in order to deconstruct the prosperity gospel and other modern bad ideas.  If you haven't already, take a look at the introduction to this chapter which explains what I mean by 'prosperity gospel', otherwise enjoy and feel free to join in the discussion.

The Prosperity Gospel, and other related bad ideas, suppose that because all people have 'free agency' - or a spiritual power of self-determination over one's own destiny- people can choose their economic fate.  If someone ends up in poverty, they caused it, and can use their agency to pull themselves out of poverty.  They are accountable for their fate - and only they can fix it.  Inequality then is simply the consequence of people's choices, and a phenomenon that ultimately can't be helped through society and government.   

In the last article on agency, I addressed how the concept of agency in the Book of Mormon is very different from this modern interpretation of 'free agency' - ultimately rejecting the conclusions of the prosperity gospel.  Book of Mormon 'agency' does not refer to the freedom of choice in every circumstance, but during special decisions for which God has granted specific knowledge of good and evil, leading to eternal consequences.  

This article will continue this conversation by looking at a related principle to agency - accountability.  I will attempt to use the Book of Mormon to answer the complicated question of whose fault is inequality?  And to what extent individuals are accountable in economic circumstances.   These questions are important because they provide the foundation for very different schools of thought on how to deal with these issues today.

Let's take a look at what the Book of Mormon teaches about accountability, and how it contests the prosperity gospel viewpoint.

Book of Mormon Accountability


The Book of Mormon message on spiritual accountability is essentially the same as its message on agency.  

We are accountable for our actions when we have a knowledge of good and evil, and when we have the freedom to choose.  Thus, when the spiritual gifts of knowledge and agency are granted for those special decisions of great worth, we also have accountability for our actions with that agency.

For those that do not have knowledge granted, they are ignorant and not accountable for their actions.  Take a look at the words of King Benjamin: 
11 For behold, and also his blood atoneth for the sins of those who have fallen by the transgression of Adam, who have died not knowing the will of God concerning them, or who have ignorantly sinned.
12 But wo, wo unto him who knoweth that he rebelleth against God! For salvation cometh to none such except it be through repentance and faith on the Lord Jesus Christ.
13 And the Lord God hath sent his holy prophets among all the children of men, to declare these things to every kindred, nation, and tongue, that thereby whosoever should believe that Christ should come, the same might receive remission of their sins, and rejoice with exceedingly great joy, even as though he had already come among them. ...  
20 And moreover, I say unto you, that the time shall come when the knowledge of a Savior shall spread throughout every nation, kindred, tongue, and people. 
21 And behold, when that time cometh, none shall be found blameless before God, except it be little children, only through repentance and faith on the name of the Lord God Omnipotent.
King Benjamin suggests that one day everyone will have a knowledge of Jesus, and of good and evil, and at that time only those incapable of understanding that knowledge will be blameless.  But until then there are many people who are just as ignorant and innocent as little children.

Similarly, Jacob in 2 Nephi 9 states: 
14 Wherefore, [after the resurrection] we shall have a perfect knowledge of all our guilt, and our uncleanness, and our nakedness; and the righteous shall have a perfect knowledge of their enjoyment, and their righteousness, being clothed with purity, yea, even with the robe of righteousness.  
15 And it shall come to pass that when all men shall have passed from this first death unto life, insomuch as they have become immortal, they must appear before the judgment-seat of the Holy One of Israel; and then cometh the judgment, and then must they be judged according to the holy judgment of God. ... 
22 And he suffereth this that the resurrection might pass upon all men, that all might stand before him at the great and judgment day.
23 And he commandeth all men that they must repent, and be baptized in his name, having perfect faith in the Holy One of Israel, or they cannot be saved in the kingdom of God.
24 And if they will not repent and believe in his name, and be baptized in his name, and endure to the end, they must be damned... 
25 Wherefore, he has given a law; and where there is no law given there is no punishment; and where there is no punishment there is no condemnation...
In order to be judged, we will eventually have all knowledge in the resurrection.  Until then, if a law is not given to an individual there is no condemnation, or accountability.

What these passages mean is that in order to be accountable to a law, one must have spiritual knowledge of that law imparted.

For example, in Jacob 3:7, Alma 17:14-16 & 60:32, and Helaman 15:4, negative qualities of the Lamanites are described, but it is acknowledged that the Lamanites are ignorant, just following the 'traditions of their fathers'.  The Lamanites committed iniquities, including stealing, priestcrafts, and murders - and were a 'lazy and idolatrous' people - and yet the Lord points out in these passages that accountability for these things is actually on the ancestors and leaders of the Lamanites, who knowingly led their people astray, and not the Lamanites in the present.

In order to be spiritually accountable for one's economic circumstance, there must be spiritual laws related to that circumstance, and those laws must be revealed to the individual; only then can there be spiritual accountability.

The Book of Mormon affirms that several aspects of gospel knowledge are related to economic circumstance, at least the prosperity of a society if not the individual - including hard work, equity and justice, the sharing of resources with the less fortunate, etc.

But as we discussed in the articles on What is Prosperity, Economics of Wealth, and Agency and Economics, obedience to these qualities does not necessarily mean that an individual prospers independently, but that a society prospers because collectively they work hard and share their resources to those whose hard work does not happen pay off as much as others.  Furthermore, sometimes wicked societies and individuals can become wealthy, and it is not at all a sign of their righteousness, but it just happens.

God's solution to poverty and inequality is not to teach individuals the Gospel, and then to independently bless each righteous person with wealth according to their righteousness; but instead to teach a society the Gospel, including the requirement to share your resources with those in need, and to meet the needs of individuals through all his people obeying economic commandments.

So, does the Book of Mormon claim that poverty is under an individual's spiritual accountability?

Theoretically maybe.  Perhaps an individual could be spiritually taught to do some action that would lead to material wealth, and if they were not to follow the counsel then they would be responsible for any resulting poverty from the lack of that action.

But ultimately there is no evidence in the book of God ever giving such counsel.  Instead, He expects his society to take care of the poor, "that they may be rich like unto you" (Jacob 2).  There is never a time that the poor are taught any principle of the Gospel with any intent of curing them of their poverty.  His solution to poverty is simply to teach His people to share.

Thus, when God teaches his people to share their resources with the poor, and indeed to end poverty by making the poor "rich like unto you" (Jacob 2), or to at least administer to them according to their "wants and needs" (Mosiah 18), then it is society that is accountable for any perpetuating poverty.

In order to ensure that His people act to correct poverty without pride, judgment, or envying of the poor, the Lord teaches His people not to judge - ultimately making determining accountability irrelevant.  We will explore this more closely in the next article.


What About Accountability for Non Spiritual Actions?


All of the above discussion focused on spiritual accountability, for which the Book of Mormon has a lot to say, but spiritual accountability should not be confused with natural consequences for actions.  There are consequences to actions regardless of spiritual knowledge.  An oven is still going to burn regardless of whether someone knows it will or not.

Furthermore, there is a certain amount of accountability for actions we expect in our society for everyone, regardless of whether someone knows or cares about Jesus, regardless of what they have been taught, and even certain expectations for children (which Benjamin describes, at least spiritually, as "blameless").

Like the word 'agency', the Book of Mormon version of 'accountability' strictly speaks to the spiritual side of things.  Concerning this general concept of accountability, the Book of Mormon is mostly silent.

However, in the historical portions of the Book of Mormon that we discussed in the first chapter, it is clear that the God of the Book of Mormon is displeased with inequality and iniquity - the forces that cause poverty and inequality in the Book - and He is displeased regardless of whether or not his people have been taught that such actions are wrong (although God does often does instruct his prophets to teach the people it is wrong, and give them a chance to repent).

This suggests that there are some general expectations God has for all people in regards to the way they treat one another - especially economically - with or without specifically being instructed.

For example, we talked about the Lamanites above - God put accountability for their actions on the ancestors of the Lamanites, but He was nevertheless still displeased with their state:
Helaman 15:4 But behold my brethren, the Lamanites hath he hated because their deeds have been evil continually, and this because of the iniquity of the tradition of their fathers. But behold, salvation hath come unto them through the preaching of the Nephites; and for this intent hath the Lord prolonged their days. 
However, it should be noted that similar indignation and displeasure is ever afforded to the poor in the Book of Mormon - either before or after the Gospel is preached, as attested to in the article on Poverty and the Poor.

So, are there expectations that a society can reasonably and justifiably have concerning the productivity and responsibility of their poor?

Yes of course, so long as there is no spiritual judgment of the poor, and so long as the expectations do not "grind upon the faces of the poor" (2 Nephi 26:30).

Let's explore this more fully in the article on Self-Reliance.

Jesus and King Benjamin on Accountability

What Does the Book of Mormon Say About Inequality? Series

The Book of Mormon contains some surprising insights concerning economic inequality.  This series explores several topics addressed by the LDS scripture and its insights for today.

This article part of a chapter on the teachings of the Book of Mormon concerning inequality, organized in order to deconstruct the prosperity gospel and other modern bad ideas.  If you haven't already, take a look at the introduction to this chapter which explains what I mean by 'prosperity gospel', otherwise enjoy and feel free to join in the discussion.

In the last article about accountability, I spent the majority of the article attempting to use the Book of Mormon to answer the question of who is accountable for poverty and inequality - is it the poor, or is it society?  While there is some interesting content in the Book of Mormon regarding this question, and a clear case against the prosperity gospel, the more potent argument the book gives to this debate is that determining accountability is irrelevant.

The Book of Mormon message is clear - do not judge others, and certainly do not change your charity because of your judgment of others.

Jesus

In 3 Nephi 13 & 14, Jesus iterates his Sermon on the Mount, which he gave to the Israelites during his ministry, to the Nephites.  In ch. 14, he lectures the Nephites on judging others:
1 And now it came to pass that when Jesus had spoken these words he turned again to the multitude, and did open his mouth unto them again, saying: Verily, verily, I say unto you, Judge not, that ye be not judged.
 2 For with what judgment ye judge, ye shall be judged; and with what measure ye mete, it shall be measured to you again.

 3 And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother’s eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?

 4 Or how wilt thou say to thy brother: Let me pull the mote out of thine eye—and behold, a beam is in thine own eye?

 5 Thou hypocrite, first cast the beam out of thine own eye; and then shalt thou see clearly to cast the mote out of thy brother’s eye.
It doesn't matter if our judgment is right, we are simply told not to judge.

Jesus was speaking to the average person with this statement - we are to suspend our judgment, and reach out in charity and love to assist those around us.  In Nephite society there were of course times when it was appropriate to judge - for example government leaders who were literally elected as 'judges', and religious leaders, both of whom had to make difficult judgments at times to best serve the Nephite community.

But for the most part, the Nephites were being told to put away their pride, their envy, and their inequality, and to honor the name of Christ by reaching out in love to others, including the requirement to share their resources to those less fortunate.

King Benjamin

Second only to the Sermon on the Mount, King Benjamin's address in Mosiah 2-5 is one of the most powerful discourses on the Gospel in the Book of Mormon.

After teaching the people about the Gospel of Jesus, and the opportunity of the people to repent and to 'receive a remission of sins', he instructs the people how they are to retain the forgiveness of sins which they have received - by treated others with kindness.

Benjamin lists several features of a civil society, including living peaceably with neighbors, teaching and caring for children, and of course administering substance to those that stand in need.  He then gives a warning to those who would withhold their assistance because they judge the poor.

Mosiah 4:
16 And also, ye yourselves will succor those that stand in need of your succor; ye will administer of your substance unto him that standeth in need; and ye will not suffer that the beggar putteth up his petition to you in vain, and turn him out to perish.
 17 Perhaps thou shalt say: The man has brought upon himself his misery; therefore I will stay my hand, and will not give unto him of my food, nor impart unto him of my substance that he may not suffer, for his punishments are just—

 18 But I say unto you, O man, whosoever doeth this the same hath great cause to repent; and except he repenteth of that which he hath done he perisheth forever, and hath no interest in the kingdom of God.

 19 For behold, are we not all beggars? Do we not all depend upon the same Being, even God, for all the substance which we have, for both food and raiment, and for gold, and for silver, and for all the riches which we have of every kind? ...
 21 And now, if God, who has created you, on whom you are dependent for your lives and for all that ye have and are, doth grant unto you whatsoever ye ask that is right, in faith, believing that ye shall receive, O then, how ye ought to impart of the substance that ye have one to another.

 22 And if ye judge the man who putteth up his petition to you for your substance that he perish not, and condemn him, how much more just will be your condemnation for withholding your substance, which doth not belong to you but to God, to whom also your life belongeth; and yet ye put up no petition, nor repent of the thing which thou hast done.

 23 I say unto you, wo be unto that man, for his substance shall perish with him; and now, I say these things unto those who are rich as pertaining to the things of this world.
Benjamin clearly states that those who have will be under condemnation if they do not give to those who have not.  And to not give because you think that a the poverty of others is deserved is evil.

Benjamin continues with a warning to the poor - but it is not the type of warning that the prosperity gospel would give, by warning them that their own wickedness caused their poverty, but a reminder that they too should have the heart to give to others, even if they actually cannot.
 24 And again, I say unto the poor, ye who have not and yet have sufficient, that ye remain from day to day; I mean all you who deny the beggar, because ye have not; I would that ye say in your hearts that: I give not because I have not, but if I had I would give.

 25 And now, if ye say this in your hearts ye remain guiltless, otherwise ye are condemned; and your condemnation is just for ye covet that which ye have not received.
Just to be sure that his message that giving to the poor is a requirement of the gospel was clear, Benjamin closes with this:
 26 And now, for the sake of these things which I have spoken unto you—that is, for the sake of retaining a remission of your sins from day to day, that ye may walk guiltless before God—I would that ye should impart of your substance to the poor, every man according to that which he hath, such as feeding the hungry, clothing the naked, visiting the sick and administering to their relief, both spiritually and temporally, according to their wants.

 27 And see that all these things are done in wisdom and order; for it is not requisite that a man should run faster than he has strength. And again, it is expedient that he should be diligent, that thereby he might win the prize; therefore, all things must be done in order.